Clipless Mountain Bike Pedals: Trail & Enduro Guide
Clipless mountain bike pedals are not all designed around the same priorities. Some maximise platform support, some focus on low weight, some use the familiar SPD interface, and others rely on proprietary or magnetic retention systems. This guide explains the differences that matter on real trails and compares the models preserved from the original DEMON article with current product information where it can be verified.
What makes a good clipless MTB pedal for trail riding?
For trail and enduro riding, the most useful clipless pedal is usually the one that combines predictable entry and release, the right amount of shoe support, good mud clearance and a cleat system you trust. A larger cage can help, but only when the shoe sole actually contacts it. Weight matters, yet shoe compatibility and release behaviour normally matter more once the terrain becomes technical.
There is no universal winner. Shimano SPD and SPD-compatible systems suit riders who want familiar, adjustable engagement. Crankbrothers prioritises four-sided entry and mud shedding. Large-platform designs such as DMR and Funn add underfoot support. TATZE combines low weight with an SPD-compatible mechanism, while magped offers a magnetic alternative for riders who do not want a conventional mechanical clip.
How clipless mountain bike pedals work
A clipless MTB pedal locks a cleat on the shoe into a retention mechanism on the pedal. Most off-road systems use a recessed two-bolt cleat so the rider can still walk reasonably normally. What changes from one system to another is how the shoe enters, how much rotational movement is available, how the foot releases and how much of the shoe is supported by the pedal body.
SPD and SPD-compatible systems
Shimano SPD is the reference point for many mountain bikers because its two-sided mechanism is familiar, compact and widely supported by MTB shoes. DMR, Funn and TATZE use SPD-compatible concepts on the models in this guide, although exact cleat compatibility and setup should always be checked with the manufacturer.
- Usually offers adjustable release tension.
- Two-bolt cleats sit inside the shoe tread.
- Easy to find replacement cleats in many cycling markets.
- Shoe tread and cleat depth strongly affect entry and platform contact.
Proprietary and alternative systems
Crankbrothers, HT and TIME use their own engagement systems and cleats. These systems can change the feel of entry, float and release compared with SPD. Magped is different again: its ENDURO2 uses magnets and metal shoe plates instead of a conventional spring-loaded mechanical binding.
- Crankbrothers uses four-sided entry and an open mechanism.
- HT uses its own cleat family with different float options.
- TIME ATAC offers different release angles according to cleat choice.
- Magped provides retention without mechanically locking the cleat into a binding.
Do clipless pedals automatically make you more efficient? Not necessarily. Controlled studies have not consistently found a metabolic-efficiency advantage simply from changing the shoe-pedal interface during submaximal cycling. The practical reasons riders choose clipless systems are more often consistent foot placement, retention over rough ground, a repeatable pedalling position and the riding feel they prefer. See the published comparison of pedal interfaces.
Seven details that matter more than a “best pedal” label
Search results often reduce pedals to a single ranking, but trail performance depends on the complete shoe-pedal system. The same pedal can feel excellent with one shoe and awkward with another. Before comparing names and weights, look at the factors below.
A good trail pedal should be easy to locate without looking down and should release predictably when you rotate the heel.
Float is the rotational movement available while clipped in. More is not automatically better; the right amount depends on preference, cleat setup and biomechanics.
A large cage only adds support when it actually meets the shoe sole. Deep tread, cleat recess and sole stiffness can change the contact completely.
Open mechanisms usually clear dirt more easily. In sticky mud, packed tread around the cleat can be as important as the pedal mechanism itself.
Pedal height and distance from the crank influence stance and ground clearance. Small geometry differences can be noticeable to sensitive riders.
Weight matters most in XC and racing. Trail and enduro riders often accept extra grams for a stronger body, larger platform and serviceable hardware.
07 — Shoe compatibility is the hidden variable. Always evaluate the pedal together with the shoe you intend to use. Sole stiffness, tread depth, cleat shims, pin height and cleat position determine how much support you actually feel.
Clipless MTB pedals compared: current specs and legacy context
The original DEMON page compared the following pedals. This update keeps every original product image, but it no longer presents old measurements as if they were all current specifications. Where a manufacturer still lists the model, current published data are used. Where the market has moved to a newer generation, that change is stated explicitly.
Crankbrothers Mallet Enduro / Mallet E LS
The current Crankbrothers model is sold as the Mallet Enduro. Its 94 × 75 mm aluminium body surrounds the brand’s four-sided engagement mechanism, with six adjustable traction pins per side and a 57 mm Q-factor. The manufacturer lists a pair weight of 424 g.
This system is attractive to riders who prioritise easy entry from multiple angles and strong mud shedding. Support can be tuned through the traction pins and shoe-pedal interface, while float and release behaviour are changed through cleat choice rather than a conventional spring-tension screw on the pedal.
Best match: trail and enduro riders who want platform support, four-sided entry and an open mechanism for dirty conditions.
DMR V-Twin
The DMR V-Twin remains a heavy-duty interpretation of an SPD-compatible pedal. DMR currently lists a 546 g pair weight, an 81 × 97 mm platform, a supplied 5°-float cleat set and seven tuneable pins per side. Nylon bumpers and shim plates allow the shoe-pedal interface to be adjusted further.
The large body makes most sense for riders who value a supportive platform more than minimum weight. It can be tuned for different shoe soles, but that adjustability also means setup deserves attention: too much pin or bumper contact can make release feel unnecessarily tight.
Best match: aggressive trail, enduro and downhill riders who want a large, tuneable platform and familiar SPD-style engagement.
Funn Ripper
Funn’s current Ripper uses an aluminium platform measuring 93 × 100 × 21 mm and a spring-loaded Angular Engagement System. It is SPD-compatible, offers 5° of float and an 18° release angle, and weighs 570 g per pair according to the manufacturer.
This is a pedal for riders who want a broad body under a trail or gravity shoe and do not mind extra mass. The replaceable pins can be used to tune sole contact. Funn also now lists the newer Ripper2, so buyers comparing new stock should check which generation they are actually looking at.
Best match: riders who favour a wide platform and SPD compatibility over a low pair weight.
HT T1: useful legacy reference, but not the current benchmark
The HT T1 belongs to the earlier generation represented in the original article. Historical comparative data placed it around 370 g per pair, with HT-specific cleats and a compact cage that protected the mechanism more than it created a true flat-pedal-sized support area.
For a current purchase, HT’s live range now includes the T2. The manufacturer lists the T2 at 376 g per pair, 68 × 84 × 17 mm, with four grip pins per side and HT’s X1-series cleat system. This is the more useful reference when comparing an HT trail/enduro pedal in 2026.
Best match: riders considering HT should compare the current T2 against today’s Shimano, Crankbrothers and other trail systems rather than relying only on old T1 data.
magped ENDURO2
The image retained from the original article shows an earlier magped Enduro generation. The current ENDURO2 is a revised double-sided magnetic pedal rather than a conventional clipless mechanism. Magped lists 447 g per pair for the 150 N version and 477 g for the 200 N version, both without pins, with a 108 × 100 × 16 mm body.
The riding logic is different from SPD or Crankbrothers: a metal shoe plate is attracted to the pedal magnet, so the foot is retained without being mechanically locked into a spring-loaded binding. Positioning and magnet height still need careful setup, and the feel will not be identical to either a true flat pedal or a mechanical clipless system.
*Manufacturer weight excludes pins. Best match: riders who want magnetic retention and easier step-on/step-off behaviour rather than a conventional mechanical cleat lock.
Shimano XTR PD-M9120
Shimano still lists the XTR PD-M9120 as an Enduro SPD pedal. Its design uses a wider and longer pedal-to-shoe contact area than a minimalist XC pedal, while the body protects the binding and the slim axle housing is shaped to shed mud and debris.
The attraction is familiarity and predictability: riders already comfortable with Shimano SPD get a trail-oriented platform without moving to a different cleat ecosystem. The cage is not a substitute for a full flat-pedal platform, so shoe sole stiffness and tread contact remain important.
Best match: riders who already trust SPD and want a premium trail-oriented Shimano pedal with more contact area than a race-only design.
TATZE MC-FLY
The original English article called this model “Paw McFly”, but the correct brand name is TATZE MC-FLY. TATZE currently lists the steel-axle MC-FLY at 354 g, with an SPD-compatible mechanism, 5° of float, a 12° release angle and four optional pins around the engagement mechanism.
It stands out in this selected group because it combines a comparatively low pair weight with a support-oriented trail platform. The optional pins can reduce play between shoe and pedal, but they should be adjusted progressively because greater sole contact can also change how freely the shoe rotates before release.
Best match: riders who want an SPD-compatible trail pedal with low weight and tuneable shoe contact.
TIME SPECIALE 8
TIME’s current service information still lists the SPECIALE 8 for enduro use. Each aluminium pedal weighs 196 g, giving a calculated pair weight of 392 g before any additional interpretation of packaging or accessories. The pedal has a 19 mm stack height and 54 mm spindle-to-crank distance.
Release behaviour depends on cleat choice: TIME specifies 10° with ATAC Easy cleats and 13° or 17° with standard ATAC cleats. Tension is micro-adjustable, making the SPECIALE 8 relevant to riders who want a proprietary system with more release-angle options than a single fixed setup.
Best match: enduro riders who like the ATAC feel and want selectable release behaviour through cleat choice.
Xpedo GFX Neo
Xpedo still lists the GFX Neo with a nylon-injection body, chromoly spindle, three sealed cartridge bearings and 16 co-moulded pins. Current manufacturer specifications state 450 g, a 97 × 91 × 19 mm platform and a 56 mm Q-factor.
Xpedo supplies its XPC cleat with 6° of float and also states compatibility with Shimano SH-51 cleats. That makes the GFX Neo interesting for riders who want an SPD-style ecosystem and a broad platform without moving to a heavier all-metal gravity pedal.
Best match: riders seeking a broad, relatively light nylon platform with SPD-style cleat compatibility.
Clipless mountain bike pedal comparison table
The table separates current manufacturer specifications from historical references. Pair weights are not directly comparable when a manufacturer excludes pins or when an older test included a different configuration, so treat grams as context rather than the only buying criterion.
| Model | System | Weight reference | Float / release | What stands out |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Crankbrothers Mallet Enduro | Crankbrothers 4-sided | 424 g current | 6° / 15°–20° standard | Open mechanism, six pins per side, supportive enduro body |
| DMR V-Twin | SPD-compatible | 546 g current | 5° supplied float | Large tuneable platform, seven pins per side |
| Funn Ripper | SPD-compatible AES | 570 g current | 5° / 18° | Wide 93 × 100 mm gravity-oriented platform |
| HT T1 / current T2 reference | HT proprietary | T2: 376 g current | Depends on HT cleat | Original image is T1; T2 is the useful current comparison |
| magped ENDURO2 | Magnetic | 447–477 g current, without pins | No mechanical clip release angle | Double-sided magnets, alternative to mechanical retention |
| Shimano XTR PD-M9120 | Shimano SPD | 397 g earlier comparison reference | Cleat and tension dependent | Familiar SPD feel, extra shoe contact, protected binding |
| TATZE MC-FLY | SPD-compatible | 354 g current | 5° / 12° | Low weight, optional pins, adjustable release tension |
| TIME SPECIALE 8 | TIME ATAC | 392 g calculated pair | Cleat dependent / 10°, 13° or 17° | Micro-adjustable tension and multiple release options |
| Xpedo GFX Neo | XPC / SH-51 compatible | 450 g current | 6° with XPC cleat | Nylon platform, 16 co-moulded pins, 56 mm Q-factor |
What changed since the original pedal comparison?
The most important update is not a new “winner”; it is recognising that several product generations have changed. A useful evergreen guide should tell you when the photograph and test reference describe an older model instead of silently attaching old data to a current product name.
Models still useful as current references
- Crankbrothers Mallet Enduro: current family, with updated 424 g specification.
- DMR V-Twin: still listed by DMR and still built around an SPD-compatible, tuneable platform.
- Funn Ripper: still current, although Funn also offers the newer Ripper2.
- Shimano XTR PD-M9120: still present in Shimano’s product catalogue.
- TATZE MC-FLY, TIME SPECIALE 8 and Xpedo GFX Neo: all remain valid current references.
Models that need a generation note
- HT T1: useful as historical context, but HT’s current T2 is the more relevant new-buy comparison.
- magped Enduro: the current generation is ENDURO2, which is lighter and dimensionally different from the earlier pedal shown in the retained image.
- Crankbrothers naming: current branding uses Mallet Enduro; older articles may refer to Mallet E or Mallet E LS.
Editorial method: this updated page is a comparison guide, not a claim of a new DEMON laboratory test. Original images and useful observations have been retained, while product specifications have been refreshed where current manufacturer information is available. Always check the exact generation, cleat kit and specification of the product you are buying because brands can revise components without changing the general model family.
Clipless vs flat pedals for mountain biking
Clipless and flat pedals solve the same problem in different ways: keeping the rider’s feet controlled on the bike while still allowing rapid repositioning or release when necessary. Neither system is automatically superior for every mountain biker.
Why choose clipless pedals?
- Consistent foot position on the pedal.
- Retention over roots, braking bumps and rough compressions.
- Repeatable cleat position once setup is correct.
- Compact pedal options for XC and larger platforms for trail/enduro.
- Release behaviour can often be tuned through spring tension, cleat choice or both.
Why choose flat pedals?
- Immediate foot removal without a release movement.
- Easy repositioning on the pedal while riding.
- No cleat standard to manage.
- Useful for riders learning technical skills or preferring a freer foot position.
- Modern flat shoes and aggressive pins can provide very high mechanical grip.
A magnetic pedal such as the magped ENDURO2 sits between these experiences. It retains the shoe but does not reproduce the mechanical lock and release sequence of a conventional clipless binding. That can appeal to some riders, but it should be tested as its own system rather than treated as a softer version of SPD.
How to set up clipless MTB pedals for safer, more predictable release
Good setup starts with the cleat, not the pedal tension screw. Position the cleat so the shoe feels natural, confirm that tread is not blocking entry, then tune release tension or pin contact in small steps. A pedal that feels secure but releases predictably is more useful than one adjusted as tightly as possible.
If knee, foot or hip discomfort appears after changing cleats or pedal systems, do not simply tighten or rotate the cleat until the pain disappears. Re-check position and fit, and seek professional bike-fitting or medical advice when discomfort persists.
Which type of clipless mountain bike pedal should you choose?
A compact pedal and stiff shoe usually make more sense than a very large gravity platform. Low weight becomes more relevant when racing or climbing for long periods.
Look for predictable release, useful shoe contact and enough platform to support a trail shoe without making the pedal unnecessarily heavy.
Larger platforms, replaceable pins and robust axles can be worth the extra grams when impacts and rough descents matter more than race-bike minimalism.
| If your priority is... | Look for... | Models in this guide worth comparing |
|---|---|---|
| Familiar adjustable release | SPD or SPD-compatible mechanism | Shimano XTR PD-M9120, DMR V-Twin, Funn Ripper, TATZE MC-FLY |
| Open mechanism in mud | Four-sided or highly open engagement | Crankbrothers Mallet Enduro |
| Large gravity platform | Broad body, tuneable pins, shoe contact | DMR V-Twin, Funn Ripper, Crankbrothers Mallet Enduro |
| Low weight with platform support | Compact alloy body and efficient support | TATZE MC-FLY, HT T2 as current HT reference |
| Magnetic retention | Adjustable magnet height and correct shoe plate setup | magped ENDURO2 |
Clipless mountain bike pedal FAQ
What are the best clipless mountain bike pedals for trail riding?
There is no single best model for every rider. Shimano SPD and compatible systems are a strong reference for familiar engagement and adjustable release. Crankbrothers suits riders who value four-sided entry and mud shedding. Larger DMR and Funn platforms favour support, while TATZE combines lower weight with an SPD-compatible interface.
Are SPD pedals good for enduro?
Yes. SPD and SPD-compatible pedals can work very well for enduro when the pedal body provides the support and durability you want. Larger-cage models such as Shimano’s trail/enduro designs, DMR V-Twin and Funn Ripper are intended to add more underfoot support than minimalist XC pedals.
Does a bigger clipless pedal platform always mean more support?
No. The shoe sole must actually contact the platform. Cleat recess, tread depth, sole stiffness and pin height determine whether a larger cage supports the shoe or mainly protects the binding.
How much float should an MTB pedal have?
There is no universal number. Some riders prefer a small amount of rotational freedom; others want more movement before release. Cleat position and individual biomechanics matter, so float should be considered together with release angle and spring tension.
Are Crankbrothers cleats compatible with Shimano SPD?
No. Crankbrothers uses its own cleat and engagement system. Shimano SPD cleats should be used only with pedals designed for that interface or explicitly described by the manufacturer as compatible.
Can I use Shimano SH-51 cleats with every SPD-compatible pedal?
Do not assume universal compatibility from the phrase “SPD-compatible.” Some manufacturers explicitly support SH-51, as Xpedo does for the GFX Neo, while others supply their own cleats or specify a particular interface. Check the manual for the exact pedal.
Are magnetic MTB pedals the same as clipless pedals?
No. Magnetic systems retain the shoe through magnetic force rather than a spring-loaded mechanical binding. The riding feel, setup and release behaviour are different, so they are better considered an alternative retention system.
Should beginners start with clipless or flat pedals?
Both are valid. Flat pedals make foot removal and repositioning immediate, which many beginners appreciate while learning technical skills. Riders who start clipless should use an easy release setup, practise repeatedly in a safe area and move to technical terrain only when release is automatic.
Choose a pedal system you can trust without thinking about it
The right clipless mountain bike pedal is the one that disappears beneath your feet. You should be able to clip in without searching for the mechanism, move naturally within the available float, stay supported when the trail gets rough and release instinctively when you need to put a foot down.
For that reason, start with shoe compatibility and release behaviour, then compare platform support, mud clearance, weight and serviceability. If you already trust Shimano SPD, there is little reason to change systems only for novelty. If you want more open engagement or different float characteristics, Crankbrothers, TIME or HT offer distinct alternatives. If you want magnetic rather than mechanical retention, magped should be evaluated on its own terms.
Most importantly, do not choose from an old weight table alone. Pedal generations change, and the current product can differ significantly from the version shown in an older review. This updated guide keeps those historical references visible so you can make a more informed comparison.
↑ Back to the topReceive Your 15% Reward Coupon
Pedal setup keeps your feet connected to the bike; clear vision helps you read the trail ahead. Explore DEMON cycling glasses for road, gravel and mountain biking, including options designed for changing light and demanding off-road conditions.
Use this coupon code at checkout:
Receive 15% off your purchase.
